Age Daily: Post E3 shit fest

e3_logo

One thing that defines our industry is the almost tribal nature the platforms hold. On one side sits the already crowned kings of this Generation Sony with their expensive and brilliantly marketed PS4 whilst the wounded behemoth Microsoft slowly nurses it’s bruised but unbroken Xbox One back to health. Of course Nintendo showed up fashionably late, brandishing its self-proclaimed “COOL” whilst being stuck in sequel hell unable to gain any mainstream love it seems. Where is the might PC master race in all this? I’ll tell you where, sitting in their parent’s basement struggling to get their £1000 monster to boot up after filling it with pirated games. Coz you know PC gamers don’t actually need to pay for games they are just entitled to download them for free.

So the fallout from all this is the yearly “WHO WON E3” bullshit. The yearly dick wagging that takes place followed by the major industry sites running the same contest and giving out pointless awards for Best in show, best of E3 blah blah blah. None of this matters and does nothing but remove us further from the 10 course buffet laid on for us to gorge, binge and consume. From every angle we have cinematic trailers that would make Hollywood swoon, gameplay to wet our appetites and promises that even better games are coming.

To answer the yearly Bullshit question #1 “Who won E3 2014” is pretty obvious really, we did. Every single gamer on any platform (not PC) has wont the fucking jackpot. I’ve watched E3 for many years now and never before have the main 3 nailed it, got it spot on and just flat out delivered exactly not just what I want, but what gaming needs.

Sure viewers can point out the over reliance on established IP but that’s missing the point completely. For every The Last of us, there will be 5 COD games, 2 Halo games, 5 Mario Kart’s it’s just the way the industry goes. These Sequels keep us hooked, keep gaming in the spotlight so the wonderful experiences like TLU, Flower, No man’s Sky et al can innovate, deliver the unexpected and amaze us.

Seeing Halo at E3 was huge for Microsoft, Sony knew it was coming and had The Last of us ready and waiting and Nintendo had another Mario title. That’s 3 Epic franchises laid out for us what more could a gamer want?

This will of course be missed in the online shit fest that is IGN where sensible debate turns into a 3 sided argument of negativity and abuse. Sony, MS and Nintendo could have given their consoles away free and the trolls would still pick shit up and throw it at the walls. So for this one night\day ignore the comments section, don’t reply, pay them no attention just head online and enjoy the awesome spectacle that was E3 2014.
It’s great to be a gamer

Age: Daily E3 2014 a bit of dissapointment?

Everyone else, it’s another game rant – one I was asked for, rather than an organic one. Be warned.

***

“I need some words,” spluttered Joe in his barely intelligible, degenerate, rote impersonation of human communication. “About E3!”

Here, then, are some words.

I haven’t watched all of E3 because I have a life and no one pays me for this shit. Having said that, I have seen a few bits and pieces. I am left…cautiously optimistic.

As I’ve said elsewhere, so far I’ve been underwhelmed by the new generation. With one or two notable exceptions, the translation to more pixels and extra particle effects hasn’t really felt like the generation leap I wanted it to. It seems reasonable to opine that this is because so many of the games thus far have been simultaneously developed for the last generation; they’ve had that foot firmly in the past.

Hopes are, however, high that towards the end of this year, there will be enough new consoles in public hands that big new generation exclusive titles will become viable. Now, they’ve been trailed forever, of course, but usually with pre-renders and we’ve been bitten by that before. This time at E3, however, we’ve finally seen some in-game footage of some of the upcoming behemoths.

The Division looks lovely. Watching the Assassin’s Creed: Unity game play made me happy inside and it looks like they’re focusing fairly closely on making it generally awesome. Far Cry 4 looks very pretty and as long as I can still spend hours infiltrating enemy bases, I’m happy. Oh and Crackdown – I LOVE Crackdown and I want more even if it looks the same as it ever did.

But here’s the thing; so far, they all still look very much like very, very pretty versions of the games we’ve already played. Perhaps that’s unfair and, certainly, it’s probably difficult to show off the more exciting and subtle things on a big stage, but…The Division looks like a cover shooter; Far Cry 4 looks like Far Cry 3; Assassin’s Creed looks like…well, ok, it looks like co-op Assassin’s Creed which is what I’ve always wanted – that and some friends to play it with.

So there’s some promise from E3. It seems like the next gen shine might finally be becoming a reality; perhaps Ryse will not retain it’s ‘Most Epic Awesome Looking Thing Ever’ title for long. We’ll have to wait, however, to see whether or not there’s more to this next wave of titles than good looks alone.

Halo: The Master Chief Collection

halo-master-chief-collection

 

To the surprise of approximately nobody Microsoft and 343 industries officially announced the release of the complete Master Chief Collection scheduled for November 11th. Containing Halo 1, Halo 2, Halo 3 and Halo 4. Intended to bring fans and new gamers backup to speed with the Chiefs story there is also a large amount of lip service paid to the Halo community.

Chief with the bomb

With Halo 2 getting the Anniversary treatment we get to play the campaign in full 1080p running at 60fps in co-op.We get to give the defend the Mac installation and give the covenant back their bomb. I’ve played this mission dozens of times on both the Xbox and PC and it really is brilliantly paced and great fun add a friend and it’s even better. Hidden throughout the game will be terminals that add to the story and help flesh out the narrative that was easy to miss and often confusing. I wonder what they will do with that ending i remember the first time i finished the game, i was shocked at the terrible way they ended the game i appreciate they ran out of time but damn that was a kick to balls.

If they could address the ending it would be good for the series there was obviously more content that didn’t make it into the finished game including that E3 gameplay demo that took place just before you boarded the Scarab in New Mombasa.

Apart from a quick screen shot nothing was shared on the Arbiter missions No word on how the Arbiter missions will be handled i expect a second voiceless Elite but these were largely forgettable levels skipping them would be of little consequence.

 

Not only does Halo 2 get the full anniversary 1080p treatment we also get complete unaltered access to its seminal multiplayer exactly as it was on the original Xbox, button glitches and super jumps included. For those who like me spent 100’s of hours online playing BR’s on Sanctuary or Oddball on Lockout you’ll no doubt be as happy as me at this announcement. Halo CE Anniversary was a wonderful re-mastering even down to the atmospheric score but its multiplayer component was squandered in the Reach engine.

 

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

Halo 2’s multiplayer had a unique atmosphere a mix of frenetic combat and genius level design Bungie never quite matched in Halo 3. Lockout is a standout map on any game considering its simple layout of BR tower, Sniper tower, Green lift and Library the epic games that played out on there still make me laugh now. I have some great memories of that map, peek shooting from the BR tower, rushing Snipe with the shotgun or sword and being super aggressive with the sniper rifle. It was so unforgiving you missed a shot and you really were in trouble such was the high level of skill involved.

I can’t wait to get back into the fight

Halo 3 and Halo 4 but both will get the same 1080p treatment along with the inclusion of Skulls, Terminals that advance the story and maybe so special goodies that 343 aren’t ready to discuss yet. Also in the package is the Halo CE Multiplayer which I have to say I didn’t expect. The original had 0 net code it was a LAN only game that helped launch competitive gaming and moved the industry away from Quake and Unreal Tournament. In fact it’s so popular it’s still played at the highest level today and inclusion is fan service of the highest order. Done right Halo CE is a viciously challenging game the 3 shot pistol gives no quarter much like Halo 2’s BR you miss and you’re done.

With so much content it makes sense that 343 have decided to bring it all onto 1 Disk with every chapter unlocked and launched from 1 single menu. No more swapping disks, loading chapters or multiplayer maps just straight into the action. I can’t wait to the play Final run from Halo CE, give the covenant back their Bomb in Halo 2, bring down a Scarab in Halo 3 or hand the Didact his ass back to him.

Halo start screen

The final piece in the gigantic package is the Live Action Series Halo Nightfall. Ridley Scott is on board as executive producer with Sergio Mimica-Gezzan as Director and Paul Scheuring as writer. This is not the huge budget Spielberg series that is due in 2015, Halo Nightfall is a smaller budget series that is likely to be released in episodic format leading up to the release of this Collection.

Halo Nightfall

It’s also not going to feature the Chief instead focusing on another Spartan named Marlowe one not encountered in any fiction I’ve read. This begs the question is Marlowe the other Spartan pictured in the Halo 5 images? This would make sense as it leads directly into the events of Halo 5, he is clearly a huge part of the story or he wouldn’t be front and centre.

On the subject of Halo 5 did I mention we get Beta access as part of the package? Not bad ey

 

Plenty more to come from Halo and E3 keep an eye out for more!

AGE Feature: Light at the end of the tunnel

Guest piece from Matt Maddock

 

the light

Muttering self-indulgently about gaming, pretending like anyone out there gives a damn about anything I have to say, is just one of my pass times. I also self-indulgently scribble pictures and show them around on the fridge-door that is Facebook, looking for validation from people I sort-of know. In the dim and distant past, I self-indulgently studied physics at university and had a pretence towards being a scientist. I still like science, engineering and technology, but I have self-indulgently admitted that I don’t have the disposition to make the world a better place through the application of the greatest of human developments to the understanding of the universe.

No, now I just use my education to complain about sci-fi movies and get overly excited about arcane technology. One technology I was excited about was the new generation of console hardware. With the exception of Ryse, which genuinely looked freaking awesome, and the load times when fast travelling through Infamous: Second Son, I’ve been kind of…underwhelmed by the games as yet. Sure, Black Flag is gorgeous, but it was gorgeous on last gen machines too. Thicker smoke and bluer water are nice and all, but they’re barely a reason to have shelled out for a new machine.
Then I took an actual look at some of those games that haven’t really impressed me much. Watch Dogs, for example. Now, don’t get me wrong, it’s a great game; the mechanics and interactivity of the city are a pleasure to play with, but to look at, it really doesn’t shine much. Except that it kind of does. There are high res textures all over the shop. It’s smooth and fluid and shiny, but when it’s moving, there simply isn’t time to appreciate that. It looks exactly like a last-gen game, but with some bigger numbers written down in the specs. That’s fair enough, but I don’t feel like I’d have been missing much to play it on my 360 instead.

But today I read something that gives me hope: http://www.ign.com/articles/2014/06/03/a-sunday-drive-with-forza-horizon-2-ign-first?page=1 ]

 

forza horizon 2

 

Ralph Fulton, the creative director on Forza Horizon 2, said some wonderful things about their intentions for the game. Let me quote a headline for you:
“We believe next gen beauty isn’t about poly counts,” says Fulton. “It’s not about texture resolution. Those are last-gen concepts. Next-gen beauty is about light.”

As an aspiring arty type, that statement along brings me great joy. See; light isn’t like detail. The light of a scene affect every single thing seen within, but it does so in broad strokes, with niceties of colour and tone, with movement and shadow. It suffuses a thing with emotion without worrying about lines and dots per inch and anti-aliasing. The first time I remember really seeing light play its part in a game world was in GTA IV, when the entire feel of the city could be switched just by changing the angle of the sun. GTA V didn’t work nearly so well for me. Sure, the models were sharper and those all-important polygon numbers were higher, but the near constant Californian sun was a flat, uninteresting player.

So, you see, I don’t believe that poly-counts and render resolutions alone will make the new gen sing. As demonstrated by Watch Dogs, that gets lost when things are whizzing past you. Light, though, doesn’t need you to look at it, because you can’t look without it. It’s everywhere and it is a thing of beauty and dazzling emotional power.
When the original Xbox and PS2 gave way to the 360 and PS3, it was like the game designers were suddenly free to build the game mechanics they wanted to. There were so many flops leaking out of the processors that they could combine mechanics like never before, weave game types together seamlessly and refine control schemes into the slick, intuitive interfaces we all expect today.
With this latest generation change, perhaps, I hope, I wish, the artists will start to get the same freedom. The shadows and the glints, the dust and the darkness that speak out of any great artist’s work will find a way to translate into practical models for game designers to use. I urge you to read the second section on page 2 of that article above, because the things they are trying to do with the graphics engine are astounding. As an artist and a scientist, I would happily pay just to get the lighting and atmosphere simulation in my sweaty hands, even without a driving game tacked on the end.

Game quality, as the old adage says, is about a lot more than graphics – and that’s true…but graphical beauty is about so much more than poly counts and resolution. If developers keep thinking like this, then maybe this generation will beget something truly beautiful, in every sense of that word.

Can’t agree more with this thanks Matt for another great article

Wolfenstein: The New Order Review

WolfensteinTheNewOrder

Todays guest post comes from the wonderful Matt Maddock

So; Wolfenstein: The New Order first impressions…

First up, I should admit to some bias. I am a sucker for a single player, story driven game. There’s been some mumbling in the press about the fact that W:TNO has no multiplayer component and how that seems like an anachronism, but I have to say…thank buggery for that! I’ve played and loved many single player games that included a perfunctory and forgettable MP component that did nothing but take effort and budget away from the SP campaign.

W:TNO has no such confused motivations. All of the effort is right there for the single player and that is a wonderful thing.

I’ve played several hours of the game. With most shooters these days I’d feel like I was a good half-way through, but I have the very clear impression that W:TNO’s plot is just finding its feet. There’s been no impression that the developers have rushed the player through any section just to get to the next. The levels are expansive without feeling wasteful, secrets littered about, hidden well, but not frustratingly so. I was surprised to find a good selection of alternative routes that I could take through any given fire fight, although my relative inexperience with the game meant that many circumstances turned into messy spray’n’pray gunfights when they could have been something far slicker…but by the end of last night I was beginning to feel on top of the mechanics and was starting to use them as I wanted to.

The gunplay is meaty and rattling, the weapons feel like dangerous pieces of machinery and they have a satisfying effect on both enemies and scenery. Alternate fire-modes and dual wielding are but a d-pad press away. You can even dual-wield the DMRs if you want to. The sights kick about convincingly and the balance between subtle inaccuracy and power makes them feel right in the diesel-punk 1960s of the game world.

The story itself is well told (so far, at least). It’s a strange, slightly uneasy mix of comic-book heroics and genuinely brutal cruelty. BJ Blaskowicz, our meaty protagonist, could easily be drawn as a bland, faceless cipher for the player, but some nice writing and characterisation lend his blank stare a genuinely rather unsettling thousand-mile colour. He’s lost too much and he no longer has any compunction about fighting and killing to retain what little he has left. Oh, yeah, and vengeance. There’s a healthy dose of that in his motivation too, which is always a good drive for a game lead.

So, all in all, I’d give it a hearty recommendation. The game mechanics are nothing special and nothing new, but they are completely competent and work well for the game they’re attached to. The story – clearly the focus of the development team – is unhurried, compelling and well rendered, although I’m not far enough through it to really comment on the quality of the plot arc. The diesel-punk world is vividly drawn with plenty of fantasy, but it has so far stayed on the right side of believable (allowing, obviously, for some suspension of disbelief).

Perhaps most importantly, I want to get home and play more of it!

Age News: Halo 5 officially confirmed

box-620x

Microsoft have finally announced Halo 5: Guardians set for release Autumn 2015 and running on a brand spanking new engine built especially for the Xbox One. Of course no real information was given but this does beg the question of what 343 manager Bonnie Ross was talking about when she stated at E3 that Halo for Xbox One “definitely begins in 2014 with a giant leap, rather than one small step.
We can expect further information at E3 this year and possibly even some glimpses at the game if 343 are feeling super generous but I’ll be happy with a bad ass trailer and knowing whether Halo 5 is the Chiefs Story? It wouldn’t surprise me if Halo 5 wasn’t a continuation of the Chiefs Story and started a fresh with new Spartans and a new Halo story line. Maybe the Chief’s story will be told via the incoming TV series and not this Halo title.

Lets hope we find out at E3

Age Daily: Microsoft unbundle Kinect & Drop price

Microsoft-Has-No-Plans-for-a-Xbox-One-Bundle-without-Kinect-375655-2

It’s finally happened, one more backtrack from Microsoft this time involving a core X1 component, yes haters can stop hating Kinect is going to be unbundled from the Xbox One, well done now back to your cave. Kinect was the distinguishing feature of the Xbox 1, sure it can be frustrating but it can also add to the experience in ways the competition cannot match. Removing it from the bundle simply reduces the base level of Kinect units in the wild for developers to target. Those Kinect experiences may no longer happen or worse be held back from their true potential due to the uncertain future of Kinect. If I was buying an X1 right now I would still choose one with Kinect, sure there are very few current titles that support it other than the pretty horrid Kinect Sports Rivals but there is the pretty great Xbox Fitness that shows enormous potential.

The other side of the argument is two fold really and hit the major issues potential buyers have with the X1 being the price and the much published inferior performance when compared to the PS4. Now I have my own opinion of the PS4 and it’s fair to say I’m not a fan of the console or of Sony but they have a clear lead in the early stages due in part to the reserved 10% that MS have put aside for Kinect functionality. Removing Kinect from the console in theory will release that 10% allowing Developers to bring their engines and titles closer to the PS4. This is all great but we know the X1 is capable of 1080p 60FPS as they did it with Forza and that is with a ton of physics and particle effects thrown in & MS have stated on numerous occasions the console is capable of this and more in the future. So we lose Kinect in future games all to close a gap in a truly irrelevant pixel race. Anyone who decides on a console based on how many dots should really think hard about their life.

The price drop is a nice touch but in all fairness £350 for a next gen console isn’t bad. That’s less than a high end PC GPU and won’t make you invisible to the opposite sex.

Anyway this topic has already bored me to tears.

Well done you moaning bunch of cunts!!

Age Daily: Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare announced

COD

This is how I imagine the pre-production meetings went at Sledgehammer

“Lads so Modern Warfare is getting stale, we need to change it up. IDEAS?”
“I know what we need, MOAR MICHAEL BAY”

What’s more Michael Bay than, huge explosions, hover bikes and exoskeletons. NOTHING THAT’S WHAT.
Story, we don’t need a stinking story.

So here we are again almost exactly 1 year to the day since the last COD game was revealed and just in time for E3 followed by a predictable November release date. Greeting us this time isn’t another MW game but something all together different. Something new? something game changing? a new, fresh approach? NO of course not but it has a new title. Rejoice internets Call of Duty: Modern Warfare is no more, all hail Call of Duty: Future Warfare. The future king of tedious unimaginative, stale, dull gameplay that will no doubt dominate sales this Christmas. Fuck this I’m going to hibernate from November till March.

kevin-spacey-house-of-cards In the place where a story should be we have Kevin Spacey saying some things about Religion and Democracy (I always chuckle at a yank preaching democracy) before some things explode for no obvious reason followed by a few things crash into the sea. It all seems to revolve around Spacey running some kind of Military operation before turning it on the US. The typical good guy, bad guy 360 spin we’ve seen a million times. Still it does allow his team to have some pretty awesome Technology and the US will of course win and once again be the good guys that saved the world.

All in all a pretty bog standard COD trailer that’s not a bad thing by the way I’m quite relieved I won’t have to spend any time or money on it.

If you can look past the ridiculous set pieces you can see a couple of genuine attempts to brute force something new into the series. The exoskeleton although clearly taken from Titanfall could possibly add a vertical dynamic to the gameplay, you can see the characters trying to scale a vertical surface using the exoskeleton. The addition of a bigger jump hints at a new approach to levels which have always been a 1 dimensional slog from point to point could the levels be opened up to alternative approaches in turn breaking the strictly linear gameplay experience? I doubt it I’m expecting it to be a largely pointless item used only at certain points during the game.

Also shown off were a couple of cool abilities namely active camouflage and what appears to be a grenade that lights up enemies and the environment. Both cool and clearly taken from Titanfall along with the Mech suit also glimpsed during the trailer. Again they hint at a different approach to gameplay with the cloak offering a tactical element missing really since Ghillie in the mist but let’s be honest does anyone see any great evolutions coming to the franchise?

The series just seems to be lurching from one ridiculous pretence to the next, filling in the holes with more shallow, repetitive, derivative gameplay no doubt running on the same fucking Last Gen engine.
But you’ll buy it in the millions and they will go again next year. Just reissue MW1 and fuck off.

AGE Feature: Bungie finally lift the lid on Destiny

Destiny

So, Bungie finally peeled back the curtain and exposed some of Destiny’s secrets to the internets with several gameplay videos emerging that showcase the mission structure, combat elements and the various player classes. These elements had been largely kept secret until now so finally getting to see them in action has given us a great look into how the finished game will look and play.
The videos shown off so far have included a strike mission which is a coop mission involving exploring and completing tasks. This mission showed exactly what Bungie wanted to craft, the sort of experience and its vision of Destiny.
I have several concerns based on the footage I’ve seen and the general atmosphere surrounding the game. The first and biggest concern is the lack of WOW shown off in the trailers. Now it’s easy to say “It’s only Alpha footage” but Bungie and Activision would have chosen those missions very carefully and polished them as close to perfection as possible but still nothing I’ve seen has really blown me away. Destiny looks solid, great fun and potentially a very deep experience but it had a distinctly last gen look and feel about it when compared to say The Division.
The Division is unlike anything we’ve experienced so far because it’s a truly Next-Gen game that’s pushing the boundaries, writing its own rules as it goes, whereas Destiny appears to be content building on all its previous work in favour of rewriting it. I guess to Bungie it’s the safer play, building on all it knows in the Halo Universe. From the first frame its clear Halo has had a massive influence on Destiny, from the character designs to the enemy Hierarchy Bungie have stuck rigidly to their pedigree which is both reassuring and disappointing.
It’s reassuring because Bungie know it so well, they know how it works that holy trinity of Weapons, Grenades and melee are all present and correct with the addition of powerful ‘Super’ moves. It’s within the more stylised RPG elements that Bungie may find success, a freshness to the gameplay otherwise so clearly lacking in the footage shown so far.
Story wise we know that Humanity was going through a Golden age of technology and Discovery before alien species came and ruined the party. Most of earth was destroyed apart from a single city that is under the protection of the mysterious Guardian that hovers above the city. You play as a super badass tasked with kicking ass and chewing bubble gum but as it’s the future there is no gum.
The RPG elements offer a sense of depth to the gameplay with, critical hits, super moves, power bars, character customisation and skill systems that shake up the overly familiar FPS action. A fantastic idea is the use of orbs that enemies drop when a friend hits them with a Super move. These orbs when collected charge the other players super meters encouraging close team work and the possibility of chaining super moves together to keep those meters full.

Destiny_Character_Art_TitanThe character classes are all pretty generic but add another element to the game. Each class as you would expect have their own skills and unique abilities ranging from the Titan to the Hunter and the Warlock. They are pretty bog standard with the Titan being the soldier class (Spartan), Hunter a sort of future cowboy (Nathan Fillion Firefly) and the Warlock (Siren). Again Bungie have played it relatively safe going with established character types that fit rigid predetermined roles with the game. Mass Effect did the same but allowed you to customise each character through their unique abilities I have to doubt Destiny will have a similar level of Depth.
Weapons will of course play a huge part in Destiny and again they have stuck rigidly to the FPS standards. We’ve seen Pistols, A machine gun, a Scoped Rifle a shotgun and a Rocket Launcher. Bungie know guns this is an area they could have really gone to town on but have played it conservative once again.
Conclusion

For me the reveal has been a little disappointing, sure the game looks fun, but I wasn’t blown away at any part. I was expecting to have my eye balls melted by all the awesome shit Bungie had built instead I was left feeling like Bungie have maybe played it too safe, stuck too closely to what made them amazing in the first place. Halo CE had a sense of wonder, an atmosphere that nobody since has really matched (Ghillie in the mist possibly). Halo CE rewrote what a shooter could do, it shook gaming to its foundations and they were rebuilt based closely on its magnificence. Maybe I expected too much from Bungie but I was underwhelmed by what I’ve seen so far.
I have little doubt Destiny will be a hugely entertaining game, full of great stories and will be technically excellent but lacking in that almost intangible sense of wonder that Halo CE had.
Nobody want’s Bungie to succeed more than me and it would be a real shame for Bungies next masterpiece to fall at the first hurdle.

 

AGE Feature: Thief Xbox One Review

Thief-Trailer-4

 

Thanks to Matt Maddock aka Monkey Ghost & Sozdanee  for this fantastic Spolier free review of Thief for Xbox One.

I love a bit of stealth. An early experience with Thief 2 on a creaking ancient PC and then the advent of Splinter Cell on the original big green Xbox have left me with an itch to hide in dark places and remain unseen. It has been suggested that this is because, in real life, I am six and a half feet tall, broad shouldered and sport hair that reaches right the way down my back and a bushy beard. Blending into crowds is not within my natural skill set, so perhaps a little digital skulduggery fills a hole that my real life can’t manage.

Whatever. I like sneaking. Warcraft? Rogue, thankyouverymuch. Skyrim? That’ll be a Khajiit assassin, then. Dishonoured on hard mode? Not a single open conflict.

I like sneaking. Have I made that clear yet?

So it was with some excitement that I awaited Thief. There hasn’t been much – certainly not much new – to play on my Xbox One since launch. That the next new shiny was to also be an instalment of the grandfather of all stealth titles was gravy. But then the reviews started creeping in…and then I bought it anyway…

I had trouble with thief at first. The controls were…fine, but not what I was conditioned to expect from a major stealth title. Texture work was muddy, there was frequent high-res pop-in and the loading screens liberally sprinkled about the city hub were laborious. All over the place there is evidence of rushed clean-up before release. In short scripted sequences, the camera’s finishes moving before dialogue reaches its conclusion and so the end of the speech simply cuts off and we might never know the depths of Garrett’s thoughts. Having to mash the X button to open windows and move that same damned plank every time is irritating and out of place. Incidental dialogue loops endlessly in some places. It’s quite possible to make a long list of things that are not right with Thief.

But here’s the thing; it’s really good. Really. I’m loving it. This is a sneaker’s sneaking game. Combat feels like a poor option and so it should; the change between sneaking and running for your life when you get spotted is so seamless, the efficiency of fleeing into the shadowed rooftops so convincing, that getting into combat feels like a failure even if you win. At the press of a trigger, Garrett goes from sneaky to “fucking-leg-it-Kev” mode; nimbly and easily navigating the suffocating confines of the city, feeling more like a badass, springy, running-away-machine than any other gaming protagonist I can think of. He even gives Mirror’s Edge’s Faith a run for her money. This athleticism is facilitated by beautifully designed playgrounds through which to flee. The city is a rabbit warren of layers of buildings and walkways and balconies, jumbled and squashed together. It give the impression of having been very carefully designed to make the simple running mechanics feel great – and it works.

The sneaking, too, is spot on. The transition between light and dark feels natural and right and never before in a game have I been so conscious of the sound of my footsteps. Garrett feels like he’s really good at his job. The city and the individual mission levels are rife with hidden corners and secrets, trinkets and treasure with which to fill your mysteriously insatiable pockets.

Unlike recent entries in the genre, there’s no saving mechanism here for when things go wrong. Unlike Sam Fisher, Garrett doesn’t also happen to be a ninja. Thief rewards caution, planning and restraint. It feels like a throwback to how stealth used to play and it feels good.

There are obvious comparisons to be drawn between Thief’s choking city and Dishonoured, but Thief is, if anything, darker still. While Dishonoured presented a fine city in the process of crumbling, Thief takes place in a city that has long since crumbled; slums that are well established. There’s a palpable haze of poverty and sickness. If it wasn’t so well rendered, if Garrett weren’t so empowered to rise above it – both figuratively and literally – then it would be terribly oppressive. As it is, it’s a fine and fitting backdrop for the action. Stop looking at the occasional dodgy texture or waiting for the high-res textures; look at the city itself and it’s amazing.

So what of the complaints? They are all valid. Each and every one. There are many points where it feels like another month or two of development would have made a real difference. The rough edges are clear and sometimes they sting. I don’t want to have to suffer two loading screens to take a shortcut around one corner.

The problems are there and they are problematic, but they don’t stop the core game from being one of really excellent thievery. I wonder why the general tenor of reviews seems to be set against this title. They seem too concerned with its technical shortcomings and blind to the quality of the experience beneath. Perhaps that’s the curse of being an early title on a new generation. Whatever; I cannot agree with them. While this isn’t the stealth game to change your mind if you’ve never been outside of Call of Duty, it is a genuinely excellent piece of true sneaky gameplay.